Posted on July 27th, 2021
Hi Brian, glad you are having fun catching Musky on the Upper Niagara River. Both the Lower & Upper River are an excellent Musky area. Thank you for your kind offer of sharing fishing spots. I have shot a Musky TV show with Capt. Eric Elenfeldt from NY and we landed about 5-Musky in 8hrs. fishing. I try not to promote Musky fishing as you know they are very vulnerable fish if not fought and released properly. My concern has always been of anglers that don’t regularly Musky fish, hook into a Musky, fight it for a long time to the point that the fish is almost belly-up, net it and then take time to un-hook, take pictures and then try and revive the fish for release. I hope anglers that do fish the Upper know the importance of getting Musky in fast, quick pick and fast revive and release. Keep enjoying that excellent fishery…God bless you.
Make sure to check the fishing videos on our Italo Labignan YouTube channel and if you have any questions just email them to me at Ask Italo throughout our website.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on August 22nd, 2018
I have not, but I know the same techniques will work there for smallmouth and walleye. Any larger weed beds will produce good pike and if are looking for a musky, remember that the Canadian record was caught by Ken O’brian trolling with a #7 Rapala. He landed a 65 lb. musky that 58″ long and had a girth of 30.5″. He caught it right there, Georgian Bay’s Blackstone Harbour, Moon River Basin.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on November 11th, 2017
Hi Clark, yes, I have. It has a good healthy musky population that mixes with Pigeon and Buckhorn Lake stock. I have had my best success catching musky in lower Chemong below the Chemong Causeway. Try fishing the weedline on the east-shore that runs south form the causeway and past the small island in 10-12′ water. You can catch them casting bucktails along those weeds and even accidentally jigging and drifting with a Vibrax #3 spinner/worm combination for walleye.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on October 15th, 2016
Hi Mark, Musky can be one of the most challenging freshwater fish species to be able to catch regularly. Firstly, they are usually loners, especially if they are larger fish. Secondly, they can patrol a large area and not always be in a feeding mood. Lastly, if they do feed on a larger meal, they can take a few days to digest which means they will not be that hungry and will often follow lures without striking. That’s why they are often referred to as, “the fish of a thousand casts”.

Buckhorn is one of my favorite lakes to target musky in the Kawartha’s. Challenge is that there is lot’s of shallow-water habitat to hold musky forage like small bass, panfish, coarse fish and walleye. I would recommend that you cover as much of the weedlines in the lake as possible “burning” (reeling in fast), musky bucktails in bright colors like chartreuse blade/body/bucktail just below the surface right over the thick weeds, and on the weed-edges. Inactive musky will often lay just below the surface in these weeds and are usually “woken-up” from resting by a loud bucktail whizzing by. If you see a follow or wake behind the bucktail don’t slow down, if anything speed-up, put your rod-tip in the water (to make your bucktail dive down a little), and anticipate doing an aggressive figure “8” as the lure and fish approaches the boat.
The Niagara is a totally different fishery. Both in the Lower and Upper River musky tend to feed on the structure/current breaks in open-water ranging form 15-25′ depths. Most anglers either jig these areas with large swimbaits like the Storm Live WildEye in the 4-6″ range, or the larger Lunker City SwimFish or Shaker with jigheads up to 1 1/2 oz in weight. Or, they troll using body-baits that dive down 20+ feet in the same areas….God bless you.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on August 28th, 2016
Hi Vinny, thanks for your kind words and request, but I don’t guide. Musky is one of the toughest fish to catch reliably and even musky guides can have a hard time.

I can suggest though that you contact a good friend who is one of the best musky guides in southern Ontario and guides on Lake Nipissing out of North Bay. His name is Danny Columby, http://www.nipissingmuskies.com/?page_id=28 He averages about 85, trophy musky a year with his guests.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on October 1st, 2015

I am not familiar with the Hamilton chapter of Muskies Canada. The fish are still in their summer pattern in the Kawartha’s so you can catch them shallow (less than 10′), and deeper (10-20′). You can cast for them and troll for them. In the near future though, when the lakes “turn-over” many of the musky will be feeding heavily in the shallower water both around weeds and rocks. Right now I suggest you fish smaller bucktails all around the shallower water structure where the bass and larger panfish are still feeding. If the bass and panfish are there, the musky will be hunting them. Last year at this time we caught our musky in less than 6′ of water.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on September 9th, 2015

Musky right now remain in their summer pattern until the water temps start to drop. You will do best trolling the 20-30′ of water around the deeper channels that have nearby shallow-water and bass. Good areas to try are: between Green Island and the mainland, the waters off Musky Bay Rd., and the deeper channels going north towards Roberts Island. Careful navigating these waters, deep channels are often close to rocks meeting the surface. Best to troll with 5-8″ long body baits.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram
Posted on June 25th, 2015

When casting for musky follows usually means the musky are not feeding aggressively, or not convinced by the presentation. Experiment with retrieve speed, jerking presentation and fishing shallower/deeper in the water column. If casting always use a figure “8” at the boat just in case you have a follow and as a follow-up to the figure “8”, have a rod ready with a heavy jig/plastic swim-bait like the Storm Live series to also use as a secondary follow up and fish the area where you spotted the follow thoroughly.

Musky in the Kawartha’s and Nipissing are the same species, but can have different feeding habits/depths depending on forage they are feeding on and location.
Like me
Follow Me
Subscribe youtube
Newsletter Subscriber

Follow in instagram